On October 29, the BEA reported that real GDP in the U.S. increased by 3.5% in third quarter of 2009. There was much made about the figure as it was the first increase in a year. The Dow rose almost 200 points on the news, but subsequently lost all the gains the very next day. According to economist David Rosenberg, once the effects of the stimulus are accounted for, real GDP growth would have been flat or slightly negative.